Chapter 3.2 Data Models and the Role of Interoperability

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

c3.2/p52/l8-10

Delete lines 8-9-10. They are redundant.

c3.2/p48/l28

I don't think the reference to 9/11 is appropriate for this document.

Re: c3.2/p48/l28

I agree that the reference to 9/11 is unnecessary and inappropriate to a standards discussion.

c3.2/p48/l Chapter header - Format

The header for Chapter 3.2 is in bold font on every page and does not match the font used for other chapters in NBIMS.

c3.2/p51/l24 - Editorial

"Information Delivery Model" is not what IDM represents.  This should read "Information Delivery Manual".

c3.2/p59/l29 - Typo

Insert the word "is" between the words "this" and "where".

c3.2/p60/l10 - Format

Shouldn't the heading "Items needing Standardization" be italicized, as are Next Steps above and References and Links below?

c3.2/p48/l21

"was the basis for the NIST study" should include a footnote for this study.

Carl Matthews, AIA, Page Southerland Page, Houston, TX

c3.2/p51/l12

"It is hoped that they..."
Hopes, dreams and desires should not be part of the Standard. Suggest rewording the sentence.

Perhaps "It is suggested that they..."

Carl Matthews, AIA, Page Southerland Page, Houston, TX

c3.2/p51/l17-18

suggest removing the words "and likely never will be."

Carl Matthews, AIA, Page Southerland Page, Houston, TX

c3.2/p51/l19

suggest removing the words "Hence" and "even more" so that it reads "It is important that we..."

Carl Matthews, AIA, Page Southerland Page, Houston, TX

 

c3.2/p51/l43

"The two primary ontololgies will be relationships and classes." This should be described further before moving on or cite where it is described further.

Carl Matthews, AIA, Page Southerland Page, Houston, TX

c3.2/p52/l12

Figure 3.2-1 shows 4 Tiers which are described on p52-56. The names for the Tiers in the Figure should match the names in the text.

Carl Matthews, AIA, Page Southerland Page, Houston, TX

 

c3.2/p56/l51

suggest changing "It will be important" to "It is important"

Carl Matthews, AIA, Page Southerland Page, Houston, TX

c3.2/p49/l8 - Editorial

 It's not necessary or useful to note that some people will not have heard of these standards. Obviously some people will not have but it doesn't add anything to the discussion.

Hosted by
OGC